I saw the Dark Knight with TJFKAK this weekend. And we didn’t just see the regular version - we saw it in Imax.
First of all, one thing about Imax. I mean, it’s cool that the screen is so large, but the size of the screen makes seats up front absolutely horrible. And that’s where we were sitting.
When you’re in the front few rows you can barely see the top portion of the screen. Plus, you’re so close up that it’s easy to get motion sick when there is a lot of movement on screen - kind of like playing a first person shooter. By the final 30 minutes of the movie I was about to yak. No joke.
As for the movie itself, it was good…but not as great as a lot of critics were making it out to be. And I should issue a spoiler alert here, before I go on any further.
One thing that was really troubling for me was the lack of realism. Look, I can believe that Batman has this car that can turn into a motorcycle…and I can kind of buy that his cape allows him to fly around and survive falls from high buildings. But at one part of the movie Batman uses all the phones in Gotham city to create a virtual 3D image of rooms.
Now, that’s just ridiculous. First of all, a cell phone can’t do sonar. It just doesn’t have the processing power, audio power or microphone accuracy to do so. Not only that, but I find it very unlikely that Batman can take control of all cell phones in a city and use that to create a 3D vision of his surroundings. For one thing, it would take a long time for all that data to be transmitted from the phone to Batman’s cave - and unless all these phones had a super high bandwidth data connection there would be no way for this data to be transmitted and processed in real time. Not only that, but the bandwidth that this would require would bring down every single cell phone network in the city.
Finally, it’s not realistic that Morgan Freeman can look at tons of small little monitors to find individual people in a city. I mean, in the movie he’s basically looking at 200 small monitors, many of which are showing gibberish. Sorry, that doesn’t make sense. I liken this plot twist to James Bond’s invisible car. It was not necessary and it takes away from the realism of the rest of the movie.
And look, I understand this is a super hero movie. But the whole deal with Dark Knight was that it is so real and shows human emotion, conflicts, blah blah blah. In this context I feel like the movie studio is treating me like an ignorant asshole when I’m forced to believe that Batman can see through walls.
I have a similar gripe with the Joker as well. I mean, throughout the film the Joker goes out of his way to set up elaborate, time sensitive attacks. To accomplish this he would need a team of hundreds of workers, which would be difficult since the Joker started off on his own…plus, he burned all of his money. Literally.
In many ways the Joker acts like any comic book villain, going for the elaborate sharks-with-lasers-on-their-heads act, rather than just using his resources to, say, buy a bunch of guns and start shooting.
Those gripes aside, I did like Heath Ledger’s performance. A LOT of the attention on Ledger was hype, sure, but he did an excellent job as the joker…especially when you compare it to his performance in 10 Things I Hate About You.
I mean, some of the best scenes were closeups on Ledger while he works through crazy Joker rants. And this is why my problems about the realism of the movie are justified. Ledger made a crazy guy with makeup real. He made you understand this character. Then you have Batman fucking seeing through walls with every cell phone in the city.
Christian Bale was a passable Batman. He does a good job as the playboy, and a decent job as Batman. I mean, I hate how Batman has to always be infatuated with some chick, and I hate how that always ends up impacting the city as a whole. But if you buy this plot then you’ll like seeing Bale work through it.
And going to the plot of the movie itself, well, it was a bit long. It seems like they crammed two movies into one, which isn’t necessarily a bad thing…a movie with only Two Face would have been boring after seeing the Joker.
Another key aspect to the plot is that the Joker tries to create chaos in a Saw-like way…putting people in difficult positions and making them choose to do something bad for their own benefit. This is a hard plot to buy…but Ledger makes it work.
I do think, however, that the movie would have benefited by going for the ‘R’ rating. There were plenty of scenes that could be way more gruesome and graphic…but the camera awkwardly cuts away to preserve the PG-13 rating.
And that’s not important just visually, but for consistency as well. I mean, you kind of understand Batman’s conflict between being just and vengeful…but then you think to Abu Ghraib and guards forcing Iraqis to butt fuck each other, and then Batman just seems like a whiny bitch.
But look, all gripes aside the movie is good. It captures you, and as long as you don’t get hung up on the reality of the outside world you understand the Batman, Joker and Two Face characters. And it’s not a small feat to bring these comic characters to a motion picture…but it works. Barely, but it works.